There’s no denying the exuberance of Italians—expressing themselves not only through their voices but also with their animated hand gestures. Now, imagine infusing the energy of the third-largest Italian population outside of Italy, right here in a New York City restaurant. The result? A family-style dinner party at Tony’s Di Napoli, a celebrated American-Italian joint serving born-and-raised New Yorkers and tourists alike for over 30 years.
Upon entering the Times Square location, the lively outdoor atmosphere seamlessly carries through to the interior of the restaurant. Inside, a traditional style is complemented by Roman columns, circular tables draped in red-and-white checkered tablecloths, and an array of crystal chandeliers, adding a touch of refined elegance to the space. Dark wood trimmings and cozy leather booths are tucked into the corners, creating an intimate setting for conversations. The walls are adorned with kitschy framed portraits of celebrities, known as the ‘Wall of Fame,’ spawning a playful ambiance.
Guests are encouraged to come hungry and with groups, as the establishment clearly states that they offer family-style platters sufficient for two to three people. Classic Italian dishes, infused with flavors from Southern Italy, take the spotlight among its appetizers, featuring optimal starter plates like Baked Clams and Calamari Fritti. Additionally, there’s a Table Side Caesar, where the waiter tosses the chopped romaine lettuce and freshly whipped dressing right before your eyes.
Now, let’s delve into the entrées. It would be a crime not to order their signature pastas, including the Rigatoni alla Vodka, Linguine with White Clam Sauce, and their special, the Malfaldine with Lobster. Next, consider savoring the Chicken Piccata, Whole Roasted Branzino, and perhaps the Veal Parmigiana, if that tickles your fancy. Oh, and we hope you saved room for dessert, as indulging in the tiramisu and cheesecake (New York-style or classic), plus their affogato presented in a delicate martini glass, is mandatory. While it might appear overwhelming in quantity, rest assured that both the ensuing food coma and the leftovers are well worth the indulgence.
Italians are known for drinking wine with their meals; it’s a fact. Staying true to the theme, it’s only fitting to select a bottle from the extensive wine list. (Given that we’re not exactly experts in the viticulture genre, asking your attentive server for advice, based on whether you prefer red or white vino, is the best approach.) Following the sipping session with one of their Espresso Martinis—which the eatery claims to be one of the city’s finest—sounds like a challenge we’re willing to take after the feast.
For aficionados of cinematic masterpieces such as The Godfather, Goodfellas, and The Sopranos, reserving a table at Tony’s Di Napoli to immerse yourself in the nostalgia of old-world New York is undoubtedly the next dining experience worth securing.
Top Takeaways
Location: Times Square, New York City
Address: 147 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
Cuisine: Italian
Price Point: $$
Takes Reservations: Yes – OpenTable
The vibe: An authentic Italian restaurant that offers large, shareable portions of comforting Italian cuisine within a setting that pays homage to New York’s rich Italian restaurant culture.
Our favorite thing on the menu: Everything was delicious and decadent, but our weakness lies in Rigatoni alla Vodka—and Tony’s Di Napoli’s version is creamy, achieving the perfect balance of sweetness and saltiness, generously topped with fresh parmesan cheese.
The attire: Smart Casual (Mob Wife Aesthetic)
Breakfast, Lunch, or Dinner: Operating hours for lunch and dinner are from 11 AM to 11:30 PM, Tuesday through Saturday, and closing at 10 PM on Sundays and Mondays.
